Reasonably Decent Bear Protection In A Handgun







this is an interesting video with a few different opinions on firearms that could reasonably be used,
to rapidly and effectively stop a charging bear in his tracks.
your skill level has a huge effect on what is a decent handgun
Id start with a 44 mag, 445 DWSM ,454 casull, 480 ruger, or a 460 or 500 S&W magnum,

but all require extensive repeated and constant practice and ID suggest a 6"-8" barrel length.
and all magnum handguns require constant practice to become proficient and accurate with them.


now anyone who is knowledgeably will tell you a handgun, ANY HANDGUN, is a comparatively poor choice.

but some handguns are far better than others, this is because of the comparatively lower power of handguns ,
compared to larger bore shotguns and rifle and the rather rare skill level, required to be effective with a handgun,
and lack of accuracy most people using a handgun,demonstrate under extreme stress,
knowledge of bear anatomy is critical, as is the knowledge of shot placement is critical,
and you'll obviously need to know exactly where to place shots and carry a weapon,
that easily penetrates to the vitals from almost any angle.

these are the two bullet molds ID select for use in a 45/70 or 450 marlin rifle
in the marlin 45/70 you can load to 2000 fps, the BLR in 450 marlin, allows about 150fps faster)
either rifle using either bullet is devastating with fast accurate shot placement
(the 375 grain gas check bullet, linked below is usually marginally more accurate and faster in either rifle, in my testing)

(btw I use gas check bullet designs cast from 95% ww and 5% MINIMUM pure TIN)
( dropped in cold water from the mold) these are rather HARD ( LINOTYPE HARD)
personally I think the 45/70 marlin and 450 marlin BLY carbines IF loaded with a hard cast , 375-400 grain bullet is a decent choice
remember your range will be very short (under 50 yards) and you will want to have a magazine capacity of at least 4 cartridges
lever actions allow faster repeat and accurate shots than a bolt action, I've used rifles like that on elk and you'll get bullet's exiting the far side on most shots, with guns loaded like that


a 12ga 1 oz slug (loaded to 1600 fps or faster) or 10ga shotgun loaded with the correct ammo (1.75 oz slug at 1350 fps) is a well documented bear stopper, in skilled hands (any yes they also require practice to become proficient)
as with all weapons proper & accurate shot placement and the ability to place those shots in rapid succession is critical
 
Last edited:
remember , it is the projectile ,its design and velocity,
and your ability to accurately place your shots consistently
that has a huge effect on the handguns lethal,performance.
 
Last edited:







 
Last edited:








 
Last edited:






while bear and other wildlife attacks, are RARE they can be fatal.
personally I think your best option in a handgun will strongly relate to,
your skill level and accuracy with that handgun, is a skill that must be maintained,
handguns are and will always remain a BACK UP, LAST DEFENCE WEAPON

and your ability to make RAPID repeated well placed effective ,hits on target!,
with that handgun, that skill & speed will obviously, will be affected by the type of handgun ,
its action and the cartridge and loads and holster you used,
and your experience and SKILL, using that type of handgun
if your not very proficient with a handgun,

Id strongly suggest use of a high quality well maintained semi auto 12 ga with slugs.
As to cartridges, decades of use in my hands while handgun hunting, and seeing the results, that,

strongly suggest at least to me that the 357 mag revolver or 10mm semi auto,
are about the lower reasonable power limit with correct ammo, using,

either handloads or using commercially available ammo.
1764531413713.png
And cartridges like the 44 mag,445 DWSM,454 casull and 460 mag and 500 mag in use,
will mandate a good amount,of previous practice and field use, before any effective & rapid defensive use.
(remember only well placed hits count and the first shot may not definitively stop a charging bear.)
Id also keep in mind any defensive use will mandate rapid fairly close range and accurate shot placement,
and easy rapid access to your firearm with only brief seconds available where it's rather doubtful,

you'll have the time to get off more than a few close range shots, so having a large magazine capacity may be meaningless.
 

Attachments

  • 1764531374068.png
    1764531374068.png
    134 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:




 
1770313253456.png your not going to win in a brutal close range fight with a grizzly bear
or even a brown or black bear unless your well armed and can accurately place shots into a bears vitals rapidly and repeatedly,
Id consider a 357 mag as the minimum caliber if its properly loaded, and a 44 mag if its properly loaded a much better option,
in my opinion, and a 12 ga with breneke slugs a much better option a bear has much better strength and can easily weight 2-5 times your weight

and only hits to the bears vitals count, grazing hits only piss off and infuriate a bear.​

 
Last edited:



I have hunted with a handgun in various calibers for 6 decades, I'm forced to point out that the ammo you use,
and the ability to precisely place your shots accurately and consistently, has a huge effect on how effective ,or rapidly lethal,

any handgun will be , and obviously the game your hunting and the ranges and angles and your knowledge of the games anatomy all become rather critical if rapidly immobilizing your game is important , and if your hunting something that can effectively tear you to pieces ,
well you damn sure better know what your doing before you piss off something that can rapidly cause you lethal damage.

from what i have seen for deer and hogs a properly loaded 357 mag with decent shot placement is consistently lethal
something like this bullet i have used over a stiff load of h110 or 2400 powder works well in my 357 mag 8" barrel revolver and my brother in laws marlin carbine on deer


this works really well in my 10" S&W 44 mag revolver over 22 grains of h110



 
Last edited:







 
Back
Top