tracking down a intermittent cylinder miss problem

grumpyvette

Administrator
Staff member
tracking down a intermittent cylinder miss, or a miss at a certain rpm range problem is ALWAYS a P.I.T.A.
you can always isolate the issue by breaking it down into , remember to logically look at the indications, or symptoms
example , if a miss only happens in third and fourth gear but your fine in the lower gears at the same rpms thats sometimes an indication your fuel pressure and volume is not keeping up with demand.
if a miss happens only after the engine heats up, it could indicate a electrical circuit failing as it heats-up
The ignition control module in the distributor is another item that normally fails when hot, that needs to be replaced is you suspect its defective
but you won,t be able to tell much without testing, drop back to the basics,and don,t assume anything, test and verify.
theres a bunch of good informative links and easily dozens of sub links in each link, it might take a few hours of reading and time spent testing, and reading a shop manual, and looking thru trouble codes. but you can locate your problem with logical testing
IGNITION,FUEL,MECHANICAL,EXHAUST BACK PRESSURE, and sensor or control failures
Id suggest you start by pulling trouble codes and isolate the cause thru a few tests,check fuses, verify your engine grounds, etc. a shop manual will be very helpful , tools like noid lights to test injector connectors and verifying your sensors are working correctly will help
GUYS I NEVER SAID I,M A GREAT MECHANIC, BUT I HAVE LEARNED THAT IF YOU TAKE THE TIME TO BREAK THINGS DOWN INTO THE SIMPLEST PART AND DO A BIT OF RESEARCH, FINDING ANSWERS IS FAR LESS INTIMIDATING OR DIFFICULT

like the old saying how do you eat an elephant ?......one little bite at a time! :D

all the answers are readily available, theres known testing procedures and listed test results you can expect, and procedures listed in the shop manual for isolating and testing components, you don,t need to be a genius, you just need to be logical and persistent and not afraid to learn new things while getting your hands dirty at times

and posting clear pictures of each spark plug labeled as to its cylinder number,
doing a vacuum leak test,do a fuel rail pressure test
do a compression test getting the compression number from each cylinder
check voltage on the coil input lead and alternator
http://www.helminc.com/helm

1996_Corvette.jpg

image_6238.jpg

http://www.harborfreight.com/5-in-1-dig ... 98674.html
so you need to find the cause thru testing and correct it.
you'll need to isolate it to,the individual cause
and if you have a non-stock cam installed it could easily be indexed wrong or you may need to change the cars rear gear ratio,compression ratio, ignition advance or timing,or converter,stall speed to use the more radical cam

MECHANICAL--things like worn cam lobes , badly adjusted valves ,vacuum leaks, rusty distributor advance weights and springs,

FUEL DELIVERY-- things like clogged fuel filter or defective fuel pump, bad fuel pressure regulator, wrong power valve or jets, defective fuel pumps and accelerator pumps in carbs

IGNITION-- things like incorrectly set,timing advance curve or bad wiring , old spark plugs , burnt ignition wire, the wrong plug gap, cracked distributor caps etc.
Grounds00021a.jpg

the basic tools youll need, are common mechanic hand tools plus....


the correct matching SHOP MANUAL
TIMING LIGHT
IR TEMP GUN
VACUUM GAUGE
MULTI METER
FUEL PRESSURE GAUGE
COMPRESSION TEST GAUGE


irtemp.jpg

http://www.professionalequipment.com/ex ... ermometer/
Wide temperature range from -58 to 1832°F (-50 to 1000°C)
https://www.harborfreight.com/11-piece-noid-light-and-iac-tester-set-97959.html
8789.jpg



https://www.jegs.com/i/JEGS/555/W89...MIoLGlpLnz3gIVDFYNCh36aAK4EAQYAiABEgKTIvD_BwE

noidtest.png


feulpres.jpg

timinglite4.jpg


vacuumgauge.jpg

TAV-8016.JPG

image_6238.jpg



BACK PRESSURE IN EXHAUST
viewtopic.php?f=56&t=495

you can,t rule out anything yet, it might be as simple as water in the fuel or a bad ground, or a bad electrical connector or defective sensor,it can be something major like the computer controls, the ECU,the connectors or the sensors or something minor like a bad ground, but it can be something really difficult to locate, that only happens when two different things happen at the same time, I had a miss like that once that was caused by a carb that only malfunctioned on hot days if I hit the brakes real hard, I only located the cause after rebuilding the carb, AND finding a vacuum leak in the brake booster, I won,t get into details , but crud in a carb and intermittent vacuum can mess with your mind when your low on experience and only about 20 years old, todays real time data logging scan tools make this far less of a guessing game, try to determine if its ignition or fuel related as that narrows the suspected source of the problemmost larger dealerships have diagnostic computers that can test your CPU,
and that cars old enough that some local salvage yards can probably supply a replacement, very reasonably, that you can use to test/replace your current cpu, but before Id go that route ID try to find and use a real time data logger and cable to use to isolate the exact cause


the action ID suggest is to beg,borrow, buy, a scanner that puts out real time data logs, and have the wife or a buddy drive while YOU watch the data on a LAP TOP , or have a dealer do it for you

https://www.scantool.net/obdlink-sx/#customer-reviews

http://www.auterraweb.com/dynoscan.html

http://www.mercedesmanuals.com/Live_Data_OBD2_Deluxe_Automotive_CAN_BUS_Code_Scan_p/u581.htm

http://www.obd-2.com/

http://www.moates.net/product_info.php? ... ucts_id=54

http://tunertools.com/proddetail.asp?pr ... CMSCAN-KEY

http://www.scantool.net/

http://tunertools.com/proddetail.asp?pr ... ata-Logger

http://www.innovationhouse.com/products ... _tool.html

http://www.moates.net/aldu1-and-cabl1-xtremealdl-and-newcabl1-combo-p-127.html?cPath=49
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Digital Handheld Oscillopes are affordable toady.
Powerfull Driveabilty tool .
Even handy around the house troubleshooting line frequency variations.
Not always true 60Hz coming in.
Snap On Vantage is what I own & use Grumpy.
2004 Software.
Use a Snap On Modis is what I have. at work.
4 Channel digital storage oscilloscope.
Full auto scanner integrated.
.Software good up to 2013 model years.
Snap has edge. Trouble shoot individual suspect sensors.
Values stated on files working correct.
I paid $100 for my Snap On Vantage Digital Oscillscope .
Used. California mechanic retired.
I won the auction.

Love it.
Fixed dozens of cars & trucks.
 
My own 87 Convertible Corvette included fixed with Snap On Vantage Digital Oscilloscope.
I have a prior electronics background .
Gives me an edge over dealership mechanics.
Was a GM Master mechanic prior also.

BR
 
set the float levels and verify the fuel pressure consistent at about 5 psi entering the carb inlet port.
your fuel/air ratio should be in these ranges
Idle- up too about 2500 rpm try for 14.7:1-15:1 f/a ratio
from about 2500 rpm- too about 4500 rpm try to smoothly and predictably transition the fuel/air ratio mix richer to about 13.5:1
from about 4500 rpm- too about 6500 rpm and higher ,try to smoothly and predictably transition the fuel/air ratio mix richer to about 12.5:1
this is only a starting point on the tune but it generally gets you in the ball park and tends to reduce the chances of the engine reaching detonation conditions.
the ignition advance curve needs to be checked, the chart below is a very good starting point to work from
filter1w.jpg

if youve ever wondered why Ive suggested no one use the cheap glass fuel filters, its because they are prone to leak, with less than safe results.
engine fire.png



chart3e.jpg

set the plug gaps at about .045, make sure the valves are adjusted correctly
Stoich.gif

Grounds00021a.jpg

related





OBDI code scanner adapter driver
http://www.1320electronics.com/16pin_ALDL_BT_USB_MK2.html

http://www.1320electronics.com/products.html

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.sgiroux.aldldroid&hl=en

$90

watch video




http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/carb-tuning-info-and-links.109/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/spark-plug-info.202/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/holley-accelerator-pumps-cams.1790/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/holley-annular-vs-down-leg-boosters.5229/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/holley-carb-power-valves.1639/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/how-do-i-know-the-power-valves-working.11157/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/holley-carb-tune-info.264/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...-the-holley-4150-and-4160-series-carbs.10736/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/adjusta-jet-carb-metering-plates.1961/

http://forum.grumpysperformance.com/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=1961

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/tune-or-problem.10992/#post-48514

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/adjusting-valves.196/
 
Last edited:
one of the areas I constantly get questions on, from most guys who are either new too hot-rodding or new to engine building, is related too,either valve train or the related to the process degreeing in of a new cam, or cam or valve train related failures.
the posted questions generally start only after a rocker
or rocker stud,
push rod
or lifter
or valve spring fails
or the questioner bends a valve
or can,t figure out why the cam wore out a lobe, etc.
and end with...Any thoughts would be appreciated."


well the first thought I usually have is.....

why can,t he BUY a house within my housing development so its easy for me to drive over a block or so and sort out the multiple issues and do a few valid tests"
then I thought,why didn,t he borrow or buy the tools required or as a more experienced mentor?
most if not all this guessing probably could have been avoided, by reading links & threads and asking questions
and "yes, I fully understand that!
EVERY LAST PERSON I KNOW LEARNS MOSTLY AS A RESULT OF EXPERIENCE, GAINED OR LEARNED BY PERSONAL SCREW-UPS !
INCLUDING ME!,
BUT AS I GOT OLDER I LEARNED TO READ AND DO FAR MORE RESEARCH RATHER THAN JUMPING OFF THE DOCK ,WELL BEFORE LOOKING AT THE WATER BELOW!"



you have two basic choices, if you intend to get good at this hobby, you find a mentor willing to teach you and spend time doing research, reading links and learning to use tools, or you have a great deal of money wasted ,paying mechanics and machine shops to correctly assemble or repair mistakes, and you learn very little other than how fast your checking account balance drops during that process

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...ectly-and-get-it-to-last-cam-install-info.90/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...op-dead-center-1-for-timing-ignition-cam.966/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/how-to-read-a-cam-spec-card.1477/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/cam-degree-equipment-tools.1759/#post-4435

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...ng-cam-and-shifting-the-lca.10553/#post-44949

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...lve-springs-loads-and-installed-height.10709/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/press-in-vs-threaded-rocker-studs.2746/


http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/checking-piston-too-valve-clearance.501/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/cam-gear-and-timing-marks-etc.724/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...e-springs-and-setting-up-the-valve-train.181/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...-on-the-cheap-well-to-start.11739/#post-55469

http://garage.grumpysperformance.com/index.php?threads/finding-a-machine-shop.321/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...k-for-in-a-good-engine-combo.9930/#post-38054

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...nati-496-bbc-engine-build-up.1420/#post-22438

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...mbers-or-a-good-street-combo-your-after.5078/

http://garage.grumpysperformance.co...uild-the-engine-to-match-the-cam-specs.11764/
 
Last edited:
I don't know if this is considered a miss firing but on my 2004 Savana 5.3 There is a noticeable @shudder under normal acceleration between the road speed of about 44 to 52 mph. It goes away under hard acceleration or just backing off the pedal. It doesn't matter if engine temperature is cold or hot. No modifications, all original and about 80,000 miles. Despite the fact that this is a heavy vehicle and with this current problem it runs very well and feels very strong.
What could it be or what can I start checking?
 
The GMC Savana Van is working the small 5.3 LS V8 pretty hard most of the Cylinder misfire codes set. time. Most Savana Vans had the 6.0 LS V8.

Checking for P300 series codes is a good start.
A full ignition tuneup a good idea.
New fuel filter also.
The Mass Air flow sensor sometimes needs cleaning . USE CRC MAF CLEANER.

GM Had issues with Torque converter shudder problems. It should be a 4L80E trans.
Different remedies depending upon the situation found.
 
Remove the engine doghouse and the front wheels to access spark plugs .
It takes me 1hour to change all 8 plugs in a Sanana Van.
A 3-4 feet long mechanics 3"8" drive extension makes it easy to reach the spark plugs. Mine is Snap On.
But any brand will work.
 
Ody I iI do have 2 36" 3/8 extensions. I didn't pick up any codes and I thought I wasn't quite ready for a complete ignition tune up but I'll follow your recommendations and do it along with a complete run through of the fuel system.
 
Ody I iI do have 2 36" 3/8 extensions. I didn't pick up any codes and I thought I wasn't quite ready for a complete ignition tune up but I'll follow your recommendations and do it along with a complete run through of the fuel system.
If the engine is running poor all electronic shift computer controlled GM Transmissions perform poor too.
 
I custom ordered this van, I would even say it's rare because it's AWD HD1500 with the "Access" package and fully loaded. The only ones I ever seen like these were mine, one time I saw one on eBay in MS and I bought it just by pictures alone. At that time most cargo vans were 4.8 ltr. engines and 2500 vans were 6.0. The 5.3 are still rated at 300 hp and 325 lbs. I didn't think they were under powered for work. For many years I had a couple of businesses and was ordering new vans about every 2 years but off schedule I was buying every year s I know them well, much better than the ford vans we had for many years before. This last van of mine looks brand new and out performs any pickup I ever had in the snow and ice.
 
Not likely. A code would have been set for Cam or Crank sensors.
Would be hard to start at times.
Advanced diagnosis of Cam or crank takes a Digital oscilloscope and baseline known waveforms tp compare to.
Not usually shared on Forums by mechanics.

I have never seen an AWD Savana Van.
Very rare.
 
Now that I think about it 5.3 LS was usually teamed up with the 4L65 E Trans. Heavy duty version of the Corvette 4L60 E but much improved.
2005 was the best 4L60E- 4L65E super trans. 5-pinion planet gearsets in 1st year Corvette C6.
 
Back
Top